“Hi, I’d like to cancel my service.”
These seven anticlimactic words in a phone call to our natural gas company marked a momentous achievement for my family – the final black pipe carrying fossil fuels deep from North Dakota Bakken fields into our home has been shut off.
Our middle class family of three living in an 80s ranch home, has electrified everything. And in doing so, we’ve joined a movement – a green energy strategy – with three fundamental tenets:
- Electricity is the quickest and most realistic path to CO2 emission free energy.
- All household appliances and forms of transportation should be switched to the most energy efficient electric models available.
- Energy should be provided through renewables – ideally from local sources, such as solar on rooftops.
Follow these three tenets and you can have your modern comforts “cake” and eat it too. Enjoy the fruits of technological progress and stop sending greenhouse gases into an ever warmer atmosphere for the next 100 years.
We were already believers in number 1 and it took us six years of lackadaisically working to electrify everything to officially achieve number 2, and we’ll check off number 3 later this year.
How We Did It
Electrifying everything has been neither expensive nor difficult. It has basically meant replacing old, inefficient gas appliances at the end of their lives with new, energy-efficient electric ones.
Heat pumps
We happened upon this strategy when we bought our house in 2012. Immediately after moving in, we decided to turn the garage into an apartment, which meant replacing a 20-year-old furnace that was taking up valuable real estate.
By removing this old heating system, we explored cleaner alternatives and discovered heat pumps, which would become a fundamental part of our overall electrification strategy, and give us the option of air conditioning in addition to heat.
Heat pumps are machines that move hot or cold air rather than create it. They find this heat even in air that feels cold, and lure it in. This makes them extremely efficient – at least four times more so than electric resistance heating and natural gas. Heat pumps run on electricity, but sip it like fine wine rather than chug it like cheap beer. Refrigerators and air conditioners are heat pumps so the technology is proven and widespread. When heating a space, the direction is reversed to pull the heat into a space rather than out of it.
Our system includes two interior, wall-mounted “heads” that bring in warm (or cool) air captured by a compressor placed outside. Our trusty heat pumps were cost equivalent to a new fossil fuel furnace and have been keeping us warmed and cooled, with electricity, for over six years.
Heat pump water heaters
The heat pumps proved to be a huge success. We knocked out a chunk of our natural gas usage and still had lower than average electricity bills, despite using electricity to heat our home.
The next gas user we tackled was the hot water heater. Like our furnace, this 20-year-old appliance was approaching the end of its life. It was also responsible for a ton of our energy use (18% in the average home) and excessive carbon emissions (3,000 pounds per year). While researching electric alternatives, we happily discovered that the heat pumps that were magically heating our home by pulling heat from cold air could also be used to steam our showers.
But we had to venture into uncharted territory. Heat pump water heaters were (and still are) new enough that I had a hard time finding a contractor who was familiar with them. I did much of the research myself. We had to become early adopters and embrace a relatively new technology.
In this case, the reward for our risk was huge. This incredible water heater uses a quarter to an eighth of the energy of a “standard” (electric resistance or gas) hot water heater. This translates into savings of $200- 400 dollars per year. Like the ductless heat pumps on our walls, there is little difference in the initial cost of the technology and we still enjoy all the hot water we want.
While these water heaters may seem too good to be true, I can personally testify to their awesomeness. Beleaguered friends, who I regularly bombard with statistics and tours of my utility closet, ask why they haven’t heard of these before.
Heat pump water heaters have the potential to be game changers in our climate crisis given the large amount of energy and CO2 emissions they save. I love ours so much that I installed a second one in our garage apartment. This second one not only produces hot water for showers but also heats the entire apartment through a hydronic radiant floor heating system.
Induction stove
The next front in the battle to rid the last bastions of fossil fuel energy from our lives, took place in the kitchen. Again, we discovered a new(ish), efficient and electric technology – induction cooking.
Induction cooking changes everything in the kitchen. Before, our choices were gas or electric coils. Both are inefficient, but gas had the upper hand due to its cozy flame and ability to quickly control temperatures.
Turns out, induction stovetops match gas in their ability to quickly change and control heat. They also create heat far more quickly and can boil six cups of water in three minutes. The technology creates a magnetic field that directly heats iron in pans, so rather than heating the space under a pan, it heats the pan itself.
Induction stoves are also the safest. The cooktop is not hot to the touch unless you put a magnetic pan on it and the burner turns off automatically after 10 seconds when it doesn’t detect a pan. This was a big win for our toddler!
And, perhaps best of all, if you’re looking to electrify everything, this efficient, safe, responsive cooking technology allows you to leave gas behind and cook food in a cleaner, electric way.
Transportation
With our electrification project gaining steam, we were hungry to cut out even more fossil fuels. The obvious next step was transportation. My family is lucky to live in a dense, urban area with amazing options for walking, running, biking, scootering and mass transit. But we also use a car and the cleanest way to fuel it is with electricity. In 2017, we joined the electric car movement (our first car ever) by buying a used Nissan Leaf with 10,000 miles on it – for only $7,800!. I love this car more than I thought I would ever love a car. Not only does its electric motor drive extremely smoothly, but it will virtually never need maintenance and “fueling” it is ridiculously cheap. I spend about 75 cents for a gallon equivalent (30 miles of driving). To drive our average 6,000 miles a year, we pay only $150. Gas, for an equivalent car, would be four to five times that amount. Plus, when I charge my car while the sun is shining, I have an immense and indescribable satisfaction that the solar panels on my roof are fueling my transportation. I am my own oilman, refiner, gas station, and energy producer.
Efficiency
You can electrify everything and still squander it away like tokens at Chuck E Cheese. Equally, if not more, important to electrifying our homes are strategies to use energy wisely, and this should really come first.
Well before our electrification campaign, we learned to identify the electricity hogs in our home and either not use them or use them as efficiently as possible. We have a whopping six people in three separate units on our property; in addition to our family of three, we have a long-term tenant in our garage rental apartment and an Airbnb that accommodates two guests. And still, our house uses only 51% of the energy of an average home in the US. Per person we consume 22% of average use.
Our key energy saving strategies:
- Hang dry clothes. Dryers consume too much electricity. Only 3% of Italians have clothes dryers, and, as a former Italian exchange student, I follow their lead, saving approximately 10-12% in annual electricity use by hanging our clothes outdoors in the summer and even indoors in the winter. For those who need a backup plan during winter months, highly efficient heat pump dryers are now available.
- Use low flow shower heads. I have a couple great ones that use half the water of an average shower head but still provide a spa-like showering experience. This saves oodles of energy from reduced hot water usage.
- Install LEDs and turn off the lights – the original, and perhaps easiest, of all energy efficiency measures.
- Use natural ventilation. Cross breezes in the summer cool our house and we use air conditioning – from the ductless heat pumps – very sparingly.
- Wash clothes with cold water. Even Consumer Reports says it’s not necessary to use hot water.
- Insulating everything. Houses that hold heat and cold when they’re meant to mean way less energy for space conditioning. We added more attic insulation, air sealed penetrations in walls and in any new construction on our house went way over code with how we insulated.
These strategies may sound insignificant and/or cumbersome, but they are impactful ways to substantially reduce energy consumption and the climate impacts caused by it. Combined with the efficient electric technologies described above, Tenet Three becomes possible.
Produce your own electricity
As we’ve been electrifying our house, we’ve also been increasing the energy production on our own roof. It amazes and excites me that I live in a time where this is possible. In decades past, even the most staunch environmentalist was mostly dependent on large power plants and couldn’t imagine being an independent, clean energy producer.
But with solar, I have this option. I can invest in stable, lucrative, and local energy production. I can be my own power provider, getting in on action that was once reserved for institutional investors and big corporations.
The financial return on our investment has been amazing. We paid $12,000 down in two separate system leases (7.2 kWs and 28 panels total) and received all that money back in Oregon income tax credits over eight years. We took part in an interesting pricing structure called a “prepaid power purchase agreement.” Not only do we get our initial investment back in state tax credits but we also receive free solar power for 20 years, which is about $20,000 in free electricity!
With our final gas appliance now gone, we’ll add one more set of solar panels to our roof this year to meet the increased electrical load. Incentives and price structures change all the time, so I don’t think we’ll be able to take part in something so lucrative this time, but whatever the cost structure looks like, we’ll be thrilled to increase our personal energy generation and have it power our electric home. Our home will, at long last, be “net zero.” We produce more energy than we can consume in the summer and get credit for it in the winter when we aren’t producing as much as we need. Over the course of a year, all the electricity we consume will be produced on our property. Our story demonstrates that a normal, middle-class family can achieve a carbon neutral home relatively easily, while saving money and relishing in the satisfaction that we are doing our part to fight climate change through these normally overlooked household systems. If we can do it, you can too!
Joe Wachunas is lucky enough to work for two incredible non-profits in Portland, Oregon — Forth, which seeks to electrify transportation, and Solar Oregon, which educates and advocates for solar energy.
Finn Juul Stroem says:
A good and proper story, which is the only way to go. All houses should be grid-free, and it’s possible, by using the Home Power System, that produces Hydrogen that can be stored and again producing electricity, heat, and ventilation. Home Power Solution is a German Company
If you then as well are changing your windows to ventilation windows you will even get better ventilation in the house as well især using the heat to produce water and ventilation, that is taken from inside and outside.
Ventilasjonsviduet is a Dansish Company.
Ira says:
I read the article (posting?) and it is full of good ideas, but is also full of ideology.
I don’t do things (like use electric heat pumps instead of natural gas combustion appliances) by how much CO2 I will produce or not produce.
I choose how to heat or cool or cook or … based on economic factors, and the useful life left in my current appliances.
You describe all the new electric appliances you now use. It’s great that you can generate your own electricity and the appliances you now use are efficient enough that you can be electrically “net zero”.
You don’t say how much it cost to buy those hard-to-find hot water heaters or home heating units or stoves, etc.
They are all energy efficient, and that is a very good thing, but if you amortize the cost of buying them over their useful lives, they may not be as economically efficient as the gas-burning editions of the same device.
My personal feelings about climate change are that the earth is several million (billion?) years old, and it has had a climate since it was created. That climate has changed over the time the earth has existed, sometimes for the better and sometimes for the worse.
It will continue to change regardless of what we do or don’t do.
My decisions are based on whether what I am thinking or wanting to do make economic sense FOR ME.
If you have enough $$ to buy exotic and costly devices to achieve the goal of producing zero carbon emissions, I commend you for your dedication, and appreciate the information you have presented in this posting. If / when circumstances call for me to replace an appliance, I will consider the devices you described.
BTW… I do property inspection (like home inspections) as my “occupation”.
I have been certified by The Building Performance Institute to do “energy audits”.
That is one of the inspection services I offer, to see where homes (and commercial properties) are “losing heat”, and need insulation, etc. Energy efficiency is the objective.
Bruce Sullivan says:
Ira,
Thanks for bringing up the economic angle. We have covered this quite extensively on ZEP. We show how thoughtful consideration of energy saving measures will pay for itself (and sometimes make a profit). Here are two of my favorites:
My Zero Energy Retrofit Beats my 401(k)
https://zeroenergyproject.com/2018/09/23/my-zero-energy-retrofit-beats-my-401k/
Financing Energy-Saving Improvements and Zero Energy Homes for All
https://zeroenergyproject.com/2019/06/03/financing-energy-saving-improvements-and-zero-energy-homes-for-all/
If you want to dig deeper, just search of ZEP on the term financing. There is a lot of good information there showing how reducing energy consumption makes economic sense to consumers.
The technology for zero energy homes is not especially expensive or hard to find. You can buy a heat pump water heater at Home Depot for $799. One important point that Joe makes in this post is that he upgraded his major equipment when it needed to be replaced anyway. That makes the most sense for existing homes. In new construction, all those purchases are being made anyway. The real cost impact is just the difference in price between standard equipment and high-performance models.
The choices I made when I built my zero energy house worked very well FOR ME. The cost of ownership for my home is $8 LESS than it would have been for the same size home built to code. I believe that if you can afford to build a new home, you can afford to make it zero energy.
Bruce